Should I Repair or Replace my Roof?

Mar 8, 2023Asphalt Shingle Roofing, Blog, Roof Repair, Roof Replacement, Roofing, Roofing Contractor

Deciding between repairing your roof and replacing your roof in New Jersey can be a difficult decision. There are several factors to consider before making a decision, including the age of your roof, the extent of the damage, and the cost of repair versus replacement.

If your roof is relatively new, has limited damage, and the cost of repair is affordable, repairing your roof may be the best option. However, if your roof is old, has significant damage, and the cost of repair is high, it may be more cost-effective in the long run to replace your roof.

1) Age of Your Roof

The age of your roof is an important factor to consider. If your roof is over 20 years old, it may be more cost-effective to replace your roof than to repair it. An older roof may have multiple issues, such as leaks, missing or damaged shingles, and structural damage. Aesthetically, matching new shingles to old shingles will be impossible. Replacing an old roof will provide a new, durable, and long-lasting solution to protect your home.

2) Extent of the Damage

The extent of the damage is another factor to consider. If the damage is isolated to a small area, repairing your roof may be sufficient. However, if the damage is widespread, replacing your roof may be a better option. If the damage is severe, it may lead to further problems, such as mold, water damage, or even structural damage.

3) Cost

Cost is a major factor when deciding between repairing and replacing your roof. Repairing your roof is generally less expensive than replacing it. However, if the cost of repair is high, it may be more cost-effective to replace your roof. A new roof will provide a long-lasting solution and add value to your home. Even if you don’t intend to stay in your home much longer, your buyers will take into account the cost of replacing the roof in their offer.

In conclusion, deciding between repairing your roof and replacing it in New Jersey can be a difficult decision. Consider the age of your roof, the extent of the damage, and the cost of repair versus replacement when making your decision. Contact a professional roofing contractor for a comprehensive evaluation and recommendation on the best course of action for your roof.

Ballantine Home Improvement

5.0

Based on 13 reviews

review us on

Mark Eschbacher

15:21 29 Jun 23

Scott, the owner, came to my home to evaluate my roof leak. Although I expected to be told that my 24 year old roof needed replacement to fix the problem, Scott climbed into my attic and onto the roof (he also used his drone to get an overall view of the roof). He was able to identify an area that was causing the problem, offered a reasonable repair price, and took care of the repair. I don't need a new roof yet, but will in the future, and will be sure to call Scott and Ballantine Home Improvement. I highly recommend contacting Scott for your roofing questions!

Jessica Meshnick

14:38 25 Apr 23

5 stars is not enough! We could not be happier with the work that was performed and the experience overall. Super professional, responsive & helpful from the initial estimate all the way through repair follow-up. We are looking forward to our next project with Ballantine!

Kayla Michelle

20:37 25 Feb 23

Scott did a fantastic job on our house. They practically gave us a new house. We had siding, roofing, gutters. We are so happy! They were professional and answered any questions we had.

Eddie Moy

23:55 14 Feb 23

I got a few quotes from various highly rated companies for roofing, gutters, and siding. I happen to find Ballantine from a neighbor that was doing their roof also and was amazed at how quickly it was done. I called the number on the van and Scott came to look over the job and gave me a quote. He was the only one that went into the attic to inspect before giving a quote. He also gave me a quote for gutter replacements with leaf guard and repaired some siding and facia. The team was quick and professional and did the job in under the time quoted. They also removed the many attic fans I had and put in ridge vents which will save me a bundle on electricity bills. I'm very happy with way the roof and gutters came out and would definitely recommend. They also went above and beyond helping me troubleshoot some other issues. A+++

Jean Modig

13:55 23 Jan 23

I first heard about Ballantine Home Improvement when my neighbor informed me that he had finally found a company that was willing to take on his difficult roofing job. The neighbor’s roof was very old and contained asbestos, which was complicated because of the special removal and disposal techniques involved. As I drove by his house each day, I watched the crew’s meticulous work and amazing outcome. Without hesitation, I hired Ballantine Home Improvement for a roofing job of my own. I was delighted that I was able to interact directly with the contractor, Scott Cote, who was present for nearly all of the work that was done on my house. Scott was forthright, accessible, and responsive to my every request. I was beyond delighted with the outcome of his work as well as the respect and integrity demonstrated by his team. I highly recommend Ballantine Home Improvement for any job that you have, big or small. It is a pleasure to discover a company with fair prices and a strong work ethic.

Chris Grech

01:55 18 Aug 22

Ballantine is a first-rate contractor. They made multiple site visits prior to starting the roof replacement and constantly kept me apprised of any findings. I solicited multiple quotes and theirs was the most thorough and they were one of the few that performed an interior attic inspection prior to providing a quote,

Eric Holmes

00:18 13 May 22

A few weeks ago a periodic leak in our living room from the roof became consistent. Every time it rained, water came in and was damaging our wood floor. Within a few days, Scott and Ballantine Home Improvement had inspected my house, provided a very reasonable quote, and fixed our roof. We were so happy with the new flashing, we hired Ballantine to install gutter guards too. Of course, they were able to schedule the install for the gutter guards within a week too.I cannot recommend Ballantine Home Improvement enough. They are consummate professionals, whose work is top notch, with surprisingly reasonable prices.

Lisa Kain

12:41 22 Apr 22

Great company to work with. Honest, fair and trustworthy. I highly recommend!

Ann Marie Gillmore

01:10 09 Apr 22

Scott and Josh were with us every step of the way In the process of replacing our 25 year old roof. We are extremely pleased with their efforts— the job was done exactly as they promised and in one day.

Christopher Csontos

17:38 04 Feb 22

Ballantine was great to work with. Very responsive throughout the process and quick to return any messages. Communication was far better then other providers we’ve used over the years. The team was very professional and I would highly recommended them.

See All Reviews